Jubran Got Judged: The Lone Democrat Had an Opening. Voters Slammed the Door in His Face.
Mike Judge and Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh, both Republicans, split nearly two-thirds of the vote in a city where Democrats and independents outnumber Republicans. Yet Kareem Jubran trails Judge by more than 3,000 votes, and his deficit grew again Thursday. Here are six reasons he failed to win the election and has no chance to capture the mayor's seat.
FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSOPINION


NEWS ANALYSIS
Simi Valley, CA - On paper, this year's Simi Valley mayor's race looked like it would be a landslide for Democrat Kareem Jubran. Two familiar Republicans, Councilmember Mike Judge and Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh, were fighting over the same voters. The city has no runoff, so the top vote-getter wins, even without a majority. That looked like an opening for Jubran, a Simi Valley Unified trustee and the only Democrat on the ballot. Jubran could not open the door to victory. In the county's latest count, posted Thursday, Nov. 5, 2026, Judge leads with 13,447 votes, or 42.4%. Jubran has 10,272, or 32.4%. Cavanaugh is third with 6,616, or 20.9%. Judge is pulling away. Thursday's update added 786 votes for him and 672 for Jubran, stretching his lead from 3,061 to 3,175.
The race has not been called. But six reasons explain why Jubran could not pull ahead while his rivals split the vote.
1. The Republican Split Wasn't Big Enough
A split field helps the underdog only if it drags the leader below the underdog's total. That did not happen.
Judge, Cavanaugh and a third Republican, Robert Clarizio, together won about 65% of the vote. For Jubran to finish first, Cavanaugh would have needed nearly as many votes as Judge, pulling both below Jubran's 32%.
2. Democrats and Independents Didn't Rally Behind Jubran
Simi Valley is the only city in Ventura County where registered Republicans outnumber Democrats, according to a post-election analysis. But the edge is small. As of Oct. 19, 2026, the city's 85,460 registered voters broke down this way, according to the secretary of state:
Republicans: 32,010, or 37.5%
Democrats: 29,212, or 34.2%
No party preference: 17,313, or 20.3%
Other or unknown party: 6,925, or 8.1%. Most of them, 4,134, belong to the American Independent Party.
Democrats and independents make up about 54% of the city's voters. With the Republican vote split three ways, strong support from them could have put Jubran on top. Instead, his 32.4% fell short of the Democrats' share alone. That suggests he never had his own party fully behind him, let alone independents.
In 2020, Simi Valley narrowly backed Joe Biden over Donald Trump, 35,225 to 34,590, according to the secretary of state. A Democrat who matched Biden's 49% would have topped Judge's 42.4% by about seven points. Presidential races draw more voters, so the comparison is not exact, but it makes clear how little support Jubran drew from Democrats and independents.
However, turnout does not appear to be Jubran's main problem. Ballots have been counted for about 39.5% of the city's registered voters, close to the county's 39.7%.
Instead, many Democratic-leaning voters turned out but skipped Jubran, as the governor's race shows. Inside city limits, Democrat Xavier Becerra leads Republican Steve Hilton, 16,812 to 16,709, according to a Ledger analysis of precinct results. That means about 6,500 local Becerra voters did not back Jubran. About 2,000 ballots skipped the mayor's race, so most of the rest chose someone else.
In California, ballots counted after Election Day tend to lean Democratic, a pattern researchers call the "blue shift". Yet even in Thursday's batch, which Becerra won with about 52%, Jubran still trailed Judge.
3. Voters Knew Judge, Controversy and All
Judge had a long head start. He joined the City Council in 2010, when members were still elected citywide, and has served as mayor pro tem five times. He also spent more than 30 years with the Los Angeles Police Department, retiring in 2021.
Judge's record also includes controversy. In 2020, during the protests after George Floyd's death, he shared a Facebook meme about hosing down protesters with septic tank trucks. He called it a joke, deleted it and apologized. More than 8,000 people signed petitions urging him to resign, and his department said it was reviewing his posts. Two years later, voters re-elected him. Despite the controversy, voters again appear to be putting their trust in Judge, this time over Jubran.
Jubran, a school board trustee since 2018, has won three elections. In 2024, he ran only in Area B, one of five trustee areas, so most of the city did not see his name on its last ballot.
4. Jubran's School Board Record Weighed Him Down
Jubran asked voters to judge him on that record. His campaign website touted his "fiscal oversight" as a former board president. Yet in June 2026, the board, Jubran included, unanimously approved a $255 million budget that spends about $4.4 million more than the district expects to take in. It cut 15 teaching jobs as enrollment falls and shelved plans for a November 2026 school bond. District officials say finances remain stable, but nine more teaching jobs are set to go next year.
The district has also faced abuse lawsuits. In 2019, families of special education students at Garden Grove Elementary sued, alleging a teacher abused their children and officials covered it up. The teacher denied the claims, and the district denied any cover-up. The case reached a proposed settlement in 2021, according to news reports.
On June 5, 2026, the family of a Sinaloa Middle School student sued the district and school administrators in Ventura County Superior Court. The family alleges that school leaders failed to act on reports that a classmate repeatedly sexually assaulted their daughter in fall 2025.
In October 2026, the parents of a disabled 10-year-old filed a federal lawsuit over his treatment at Atherwood Elementary. They say staff took his speech device and kept him in the principal's office, refusing to let him call his mother. The suit says his father had warned district leaders and the board in writing the day before, after staff first took the device. The claims in both cases have not been proven in court.
None of the suits names Jubran, but the Sinaloa and Atherwood cases cover events during his time on the board. In his 2024 race, Jubran said student safety had been a priority since he joined the board and called for more fencing, cameras and controlled entrances. The Ledger found no public statement from him about either lawsuit. Trustees are often advised not to discuss pending lawsuits. For a candidate selling his oversight skills, the district's troubles may have made that pitch harder.
5. Party Ties Made Crossover Votes Harder to Win
Party names are not on the city ballot, but both parties' allies took sides, and Jubran's Democratic backing may have cost him crossover voters.
Jubran's backers included the Simi Valley Democrats, the Central Coast Labor Council and Democratic Rep. Julia Brownley, according to Indivisible Ventura, a progressive group that also endorsed him.
Judge's backers included the Ventura County Republicans, former Rep. Mike Garcia and former Mayor Keith Mashburn, the guide says.
Jubran ran on skills, not party. "An engineering mindset is what is required," he said at a September 2026 forum.
But one published letter backing him urged voters to elect "a Democratic majority" on the council, a message that may have turned off voters in a Republican-leaning city.
6. Cavanaugh May Have Pulled Votes From Jubran
The split-vote theory assumes Cavanaugh's voters would have chosen Judge if she had not run. That may not be true. Though a Republican, she ran on themes that draw moderates, such as housing young families can afford and a long-range "Vision 2050" plan.
She also had police backing. The Simi Valley Police Officers Association's political action committee reported spending $27,512.50 to support her as of Aug. 25, 2026, including $10,000 for a video ad, according to a city filing. Filings posted on the city's website show no such spending for Judge, himself a retired police officer. That gave her a public safety pitch for moderates who might otherwise have backed Jubran.
If some of her 6,616 voters would have picked Jubran in a two-way race, she cost him votes, not just Judge.
What Happens Next
Most remaining ballots are mail ballots, the county says. It will post new counts through Nov. 23, 2026, and certify the results after a Nov. 25, 2026, deadline for fixing signature problems.
If Judge's lead holds, he will run City Council meetings for two years and cast one of five council votes. Jubran keeps his board seat.
The lesson for the next candidate who tries Jubran's path is simple. A split field helps the underdog only when it shrinks the front-runner and the underdog holds his own base. This year, neither happened.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
