Jury Trial Could Put SVUSD Sinaloa's Shawn Rumble and Mandy Hardin on the Stand

Bordin Semmer, the law firm for Principal Shawn Rumble, Assistant Principal Mandy Hardin and Simi Valley Unified, paid to keep a jury trial in play. The lawsuit says a classmate groped and attacked a female Sinaloa student in class.

FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSOPINIONEDUCATION

Adam R Loew

11/12/20266 min read

SIMI VALLEY, Calif. — Both sides in a lawsuit over the alleged assaults of a female Sinaloa Middle School student now want a jury to decide the case. If it goes to trial, top school leaders may be called to testify under oath, in public. They include Simi Valley Unified Superintendent Hani Youssef, Assistant Superintendent Sean Goldman, Sinaloa Principal Shawn Rumble and Assistant Principal Mandy Hardin. The suit says the district negligently failed to protect the Sinaloa student from repeated groping by a classmate.

What's Happening

The Sinaloa student's mother sued the Simi Valley Unified School District and three administrators on her behalf in June 2026. The suit says that starting around August 2025, a classmate groped her genital area at least 10 times, both over and under her underwear. It says the classmate also pulled her hair and attacked her many times.

The Sinaloa student told her mother about the abuse in early October 2025, the suit says. Her parents then emailed Mr. Rumble, called Ms. Hardin and reported the assaults to the Simi Valley Police Department. The suit says the school never investigated and never reported the abuse to the police or a child welfare agency. Her parents moved her to another school.

The family seeks money for therapy, academic support, lost learning and emotional distress, but does not name an amount.

On Nov. 5, 2026, lawyers for Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin paid the $150 jury fee in Ventura County Superior Court to keep their right to a jury trial. The fee also covers the district and Mr. Goldman.

The payment came about two weeks before an early check-in hearing, called a case management conference, set for Nov. 20.

The case is in active litigation, which will test the allegations. In an Oct. 29, 2026, court filing, the district, Mr. Goldman, Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin denied the claims and asked the court to rule that the family should get nothing.

The Ledger is not naming the Sinaloa student, who is a minor, or her parents, to protect her privacy.

An amended complaint the family filed Sept. 29, 2026, says Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin were aware of the classmate's "ongoing misconduct" and "the need for heightened supervision." It also says:

  • The classmate pulled her hair "when no one was looking," the suit says. It describes the school day as "a war zone" for her.

  • On Sept. 9, 2025, the school nurse called her father to say she had a severe headache. A doctor later said stress at school was affecting her health, according to the suit.

  • Staff never told her parents about the incidents, the suit says.

The suit says a case was opened under Title IX, the federal law that bans sex discrimination in schools, including sexual harassment. The investigator the district hired went to one meeting but never finished the investigation or issued a written decision, according to the complaint.

The family also says the district never answered a formal claim it filed on Jan. 6, 2026, a step state law generally requires before suing a public agency.

The suit makes two main legal claims:

  • Negligence, against all of the defendants. It says the district and the four administrators had a duty to supervise and protect students, and failed to do so.

  • Negligent training and supervision, against the district. It says the district did not train its staff to spot, stop and report misconduct between students.

The suit also says staff broke California's Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act by not reporting the abuse to the police or a child welfare agency. It does not say how the family knows no report was made. Only school, police or child welfare records would show that. The complaint also points to the state's child endangerment law.

In their Oct. 29 answer, lawyers for the district, Mr. Goldman, Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin write that the four "were not negligent in any fashion." The filing lists 59 legal defenses, including these:

  • The district had policies to prevent harassment. If it was told about the abuse, it "took prompt and effective action."

  • Staff carried out their required duties "with reasonable diligence."

  • The Sinaloa student was hurt by a "random act of violence" by someone the school did not control and could not have predicted.

  • The suit "misrepresents known facts" and exaggerates her injuries, so the defendants should be repaid their legal fees.

Even as it says the four were not negligent, the filing argues that some of the fault lies with the Sinaloa student, who was in middle school at the time. It says her "own negligence" contributed to her injuries, that she "assumed the risk of injury" and that she "could have avoided the harm alleged by taking reasonable steps." The harm the lawsuit describes is the repeated groping and attacks in her classroom. Defense lawyers often list such defenses early in a case as a precaution.

Some of the defenses do not appear to fit the facts of this case. Two say the incident happened off campus, one after school and one before school. The complaint says the assaults happened in a classroom. Others refer to unsafe property, building design and a special education law.

The family added Dr. Youssef as a defendant in the amended complaint. It argues that the duty to protect students extends to "the school superintendent and other administrative personnel" who oversee schools, including Dr. Youssef and Mr. Goldman.

Dr. Youssef is not part of the jury fee notice or the Oct. 29 answer, which was filed "for no other party" than the district, Mr. Goldman, Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin. The court's docket lists no lawyer for him, and the filings do not say whether he has been served. That could mean he has not yet been served or has not yet responded.

Why It Matters

A jury trial would put the school's handling of the case in front of the public. State law lets the family's lawyers call the defendants and district employees to testify under oath. Their answers could fill in what the court filings so far leave out, such as what staff knew, when they knew it and whether anyone reported the abuse to the police.

The case could also matter outside civil court, though nothing in the lawsuit says that anyone at the school has been accused of a crime. The family's suit asks for money, not jail time, and a civil jury decides only whether a claim is more likely true than not. A criminal case would be separate. Only prosecutors can bring one, and they would have to prove a crime beyond a reasonable doubt.

Evidence from the civil case could lead to a criminal investigation. Records and sworn testimony gathered for the suit, and anything said in court, could be turned over to the Ventura County District Attorney's Office and the Simi Valley Police Department. A judge can limit how some records are shared. The family can also give investigators its own records at any time. Prosecutors would then decide whether to file charges.

California law makes it a crime for a mandated reporter, such as a teacher or principal, to fail to report known or suspected child abuse. It is a misdemeanor that carries up to six months in jail, a $1,000 fine or both. For a failure to report a sexual assault, prosecutors have five years to file charges.

To win a conviction, prosecutors would have to prove that a staff member learned of the abuse on the job and did not report it. The law requires a phone report right away and a written report within 36 hours. If someone deliberately hides a failure to report known abuse, the crime continues until authorities find out.

The filings do not say what police did with the family's October 2025 report. Anyone questioned in the civil case can refuse to answer questions that could be used against them in a criminal case. Still, if evidence gathered for the lawsuit, or testimony at trial, suggests that a staff member failed to report the abuse, that person could face a separate criminal case.

The Big Picture

The suit suggests the problem is a pattern. It says the failure to fully investigate "seems to be a constant issue with Simi Valley Unified School District," though it does not describe other cases.

School leaders elsewhere in California have faced criminal charges for not reporting abuse by students. In 2022, the San Bernardino County district attorney charged two assistant principals at Carter High School in Rialto, which the district attorney called the first such case against school officials in that county. Prosecutors said the two were told that a male student had sexually assaulted girls on campus and did not report it to the police.

The next step is the Nov. 20 hearing in Department 40, which handles civil trials at the Hall of Justice in Ventura. Court filings list Judge Mark S. Borrell for the case, but the court's website now shows the department without an assigned judge.

Under state court rules, the judge and lawyers may discuss whether a jury will hear the case, when it will be ready for trial, whether the two sides will try mediation and how they will share evidence.

The Sinaloa student is represented by Andrea M. Tytell and Corinne L. Christensen of the Law Offices of Andrea M. Tytell in Redondo Beach.

The district, Mr. Goldman, Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin are represented by Joshua Bordin-Wosk and Benjamin A. Sampson of Bordin Semmer in El Segundo. The district, Dr. Youssef, Mr. Goldman, Mr. Rumble and Ms. Hardin did not respond to requests for comment from The Ledger.

The case is H.H. v. Simi Valley Unified School District, No. 2026CUPP067419. It can be looked up on the court's public case portal.

Court papers mostly spell Mr. Rumble's name as "Bumble" and Mr. Goldman's as "Golden."

The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026

The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.

We are telling Simi Valley's Story

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.