Police Officer Association Endorsed Candidate Picks Trail After Simi Valley Election Night
The Simi Valley Police Officers' Association backed the mayor and three City Council candidates. Early returns show all four trailing, including a retired police officer.
FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSCOMMUNITYSIMI VALLEY POLITICSOPINION


SIMI VALLEY, Calif. — Last school year, Simi Valley's public schools were left with no school resource officers, the police officers assigned to campuses. The union that represents the city's officers pushed city and school leaders to bring them back. When classes began in August, two were on duty again.
On Tuesday, that same union had a rough night at the polls.
The Simi Valley Police Officers' Association endorsed four candidates in contested races for mayor and City Council. Its political action committee spent at least $56,000 to help them win. As of Wednesday afternoon, all four were trailing, according to semifinal election night results from the Ventura County elections office.
Here is where the union's candidates stood:
Mayor: Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh was in third place with about 21 percent of the vote. Councilman Mike Judge led with 42.5 percent.
District 1: Councilman Joseph Ayala, whom the council appointed last year, trailed Jill Abele by 78 votes.
District 2: Richard Perini trailed Sam Cohen, 57 percent to 43 percent.
District 4: Debra Dickerson, a retired police officer, ran third behind Ivana Christmann and Josh Gray.
The union's only sure win came in a race with no opponent. Brian Dennert, who chairs the Rancho Simi Recreation and Park District board, ran unopposed for another four-year term.
The count is not over, and the county's next update is due Thursday by 5 p.m. The District 1 race is close enough to flip. The other three would need big swings.
Even so, the early numbers point to a setback for a group with a strong voice at City Hall and a visible role in the community. The association represents the city's police officers and sergeants and bargains with the city over their pay. Its current contract ends in June 2027. The council that negotiates the next one may look very different from the one the union hoped to elect.
A $56,000 Bet
The association posted its picks on its 2026 endorsements page. It said it reviewed each candidate's record, sent a detailed questionnaire and held an in-person interview with its board.
The page says its endorsed candidates are "the 'best' on the key and critical areas" the union cares about. Those include knowledge of police work, support for police staffing and training, and careful spending of public money.
The union backed those words with cash. Reports its political action committee filed with the city in late August show independent spending for four candidates. Independent spending is money a group spends on its own ads, apart from a candidate's campaign. The spending broke down this way:
Ms. Cavanaugh: $27,512.50 for videos and for digital and social media ads.
Ms. Dickerson: $17,487.50 for social media ads, text messages and consulting.
Mr. Ayala: $8,487.50 for digital and social media ads, design work and text messages.
Mr. Perini: $2,512.50 for digital ads, design work and consulting.
Those reports cover spending through Aug. 25. The city's campaign disclosure page lists no later spending reports from the committee. The final total could be higher.
The Union's Biggest Bet Runs Third
The union put more money into the mayor's race than any other. So far, it has the least to show for it.
Ms. Cavanaugh, a bank executive, joined the council in 2016. The council chose her as mayor in January 2025, after Mayor Fred Thomas died. This fall, she asked voters for a full two-year term.
She made the union's backing the center of her pitch. Her endorsements page billed her as "your only candidate endorsed by our local public safety agency." The union is the officers' labor group, not part of the Police Department. It spent $27,512.50 on videos and online ads for her.
That did not carry her far. Ms. Cavanaugh had 6,246 votes, about 21 percent, which put her in third place. The union's spending came to about $4.40 for every vote she has received so far.
Voters still appear ready to put a former police officer in the mayor's office. He just was not the union's choice. Mr. Judge, who retired from the Los Angeles Police Department in 2021 after 31 years in law enforcement, led with 12,661 votes, or 42.5 percent. He has served on the council since 2010 and gave up his District 2 seat to run.
Even one of the union's own picks went another way. Mr. Dennert, the park board chairman the union endorsed, is listed as a supporter on the campaign website of a rival, Kareem Jubran.
A 78-Vote Race
The closest race involved the seat Ms. Cavanaugh gave up when she became mayor.
In February 2025, the council interviewed applicants for the District 1 opening. It chose Mr. Ayala, a business executive and college lecturer, on a 3-to-1 vote. Mr. Judge cast the only no vote. Ms. Abele and Anthony Thompson had also applied for the job. This fall, both ran against Mr. Ayala.
Mr. Ayala ran with broad labor support. Besides the police union, he was endorsed by the Central Coast Labor Council and SEIU Local 721, which represents many city workers.
It was not enough on election night. Ms. Abele, a retired businesswoman, had 2,964 votes, or 38.4 percent. Mr. Ayala had 2,886 votes, or 37.3 percent. Mr. Thompson had 16.5 percent, and Todd Taylor had 7.8 percent.
A 78-vote gap can close as late ballots come in. The winner will serve the rest of the term.
Mr. Ayala and the union did not always agree. He and Mr. Judge sit on a city working group on school resource officers, the police officers assigned to campuses. The union wanted the program expanded. Mr. Ayala said the group should study the need first, before setting a staffing target.
Two Open Seats Slipping Away
The union also came up short in the two council races with no incumbent.
In District 2, the seat Mr. Judge is leaving, the union backed Mr. Perini. He founded a local security and technology company and is a state-certified electrician. He faced Mr. Cohen, an engineer who has led a neighborhood council.
Mr. Cohen led with 3,788 votes to Mr. Perini's 2,850, a gap of 938 votes. The union spent less on Mr. Perini than on any of its other city candidates.
In District 4, Councilman Rocky Rhodes did not seek re-election. The union backed Ms. Dickerson, a retired Los Angeles police officer and pilot with 27 years in law enforcement. Only Ms. Cavanaugh got more of the union's money.
During the campaign, Ms. Dickerson said the two officers now assigned to the city's 28 schools are not enough. She called for at least four and ideally six. She also backed Measure A, a hotel tax increase.
Ms. Christmann, a business owner and planning commissioner, took a different line. She opposed Measure A and any new tax for school officers. "It doesn't matter if it's for SROs or for anything else," she said during the race. Both women said the school district should help pay for campus officers.
Ms. Christmann led with 3,319 votes, or 38.4 percent. Mr. Gray, a business advocate and former park board member, had 28.3 percent. Ms. Dickerson had 24.8 percent, and Scott Juceam had 8.5 percent. Ms. Dickerson trailed the leader by 1,174 votes.
Why Voters Went Another Way
No one surveyed voters, so no one can say for sure why the union's picks fell short. But the results and the campaigns point to a few patterns.
Voters did not turn on the police. They backed a different retired officer for mayor. Mr. Judge has said four school officers would be ideal, twice the number on campus now.
Two union picks were facing voters in their jobs for the first time. The council appointed Ms. Cavanaugh as mayor and Mr. Ayala to the council in early 2025. Ms. Cavanaugh's last council race had been unopposed.
Party groups took sides. City races are officially nonpartisan. Still, the Ventura County Democratic Party backed Mr. Cohen and Mr. Jubran. Mr. Judge's campaign lists the Ventura County Young Republicans among his endorsers.
Some front-runners ran on costs. In District 1, Ms. Abele warned about $240 million in unfunded pension and retiree health costs. She said those costs squeeze money for roads and police. She opposed new taxes to cover them but backed competitive police pay. Ms. Christmann opposed new taxes, too.
Voters were not against every tax. Citywide, they approved Measure A with about 71 percent of the vote. It raises the tax on hotel and short-term rental stays from 10 percent to 12 percent. Supporters said it could bring about $400,000 a year into the general fund, which pays for police.
What Is at Stake
The city's current contract with the officers' association is a two-year deal. It gives officers 5 percent raises in 2025 and 2026. It also drops the three lowest steps on the pay scale. The city estimated the cost at about $4.2 million over two years, paid from the general fund. The council approved the deal unanimously in November 2025.
That contract ends June 30, 2027. The next round of talks will fall to the new council.
If the early results hold, only two members of today's council would stay on. Mr. Judge would move up to mayor. Councilwoman Elaine Litster, whose seat was not on the ballot, would remain. The other three seats would go to people the union did not endorse.
The union's reach goes beyond the bargaining table. It supports youth sports, school programs and community events. It also has a charity that helps officers whose careers ended because of injuries.
Its biggest recent push was on school safety. During the 2025-26 school year, Simi Valley Unified's school resource officer program dropped to zero officers. One officer had retired, and another was on leave. The union urged the city to restore the program and grow it.
In a June position statement, the union said two officers are not enough for a district with more than 17,000 students and staff on 28 campuses. It argued that "every child deserves to learn in a safe, stable environment."
The two officers now on campus are Officer Amanda Torres, who covers the east end of the city, and Officer Silvano Gonzalez, who covers the west end.
The union has said two is still too few. This spring, city and school leaders formed a working group to study staffing and how to share the cost. Several of the city leaders who will act on its advice will soon be new to the job.
What Comes Next
The county will keep counting ballots in the days ahead. It has 30 days after the election to certify the results.
As of Wednesday, the county had counted ballots from about 37 percent of its registered voters. The District 1 race, with its 78-vote gap, is the one to watch.
For the officers' association, the bigger test may come at the bargaining table. If the early count holds, the union will sit across from a council it mostly did not choose.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
