Sexual Abuse Lawsuits and Falling Scores for Latino and Black Students Mark Dawn Smollen's Tenure. Now She Wants a Park Board Seat.
Dawn Smollen, the Simi Valley Unified School District Board President, is running for the board of the park district that runs after-school programs on Simi Valley's school campuses, including the one where a 5-year-old says an older student sexually assaulted her.
FEATUREDOPINIONSIMI VALLEY NEWSOPINIONEDUCATION


SIMI VALLEY, Calif. — Dawn Smollen has spent eight years on the Simi Valley Unified School District board. In that time, the district has been sued over the alleged sexual assault of a 5-year-old, the repeated groping of a middle school girl and the sexual harassment of a high school student. Its test scores have slipped below where they were before she joined the board: about half its students do not meet state standards in English, and more than three in five fall short in math. Scores for Latino and Black students have dropped since she took office and trail those of white classmates by about 15 to 20 percentage points. Now Ms. Smollen, the board's president, is running for the Rancho Simi Recreation and Park District board on that record.
The lawsuits are still pending. None of those described here name Ms. Smollen as a defendant, accuse her of misconduct or claim she knew of the abuse of children alleged in them; the complaint in the most recent federal case was not available. The question they raise is what the district's leaders, including its board, did to keep children safe.
Barred by term limits from seeking re-election, Ms. Smollen is running for the park board's Division 2 seat in the Nov. 3 election. The two jobs overlap closely. The park district runs after-school clubs on elementary campuses, including the one where the 5-year-old says she was assaulted. It is also a co-defendant in the lawsuit filed by the girl's family, which is set for trial in January.
Sexual Assault Claims, From Age 5 to High School
A 5-year-old and a lost video. The girl's family says an older student sexually assaulted her on Feb. 7, 2024, during the park district's after-school club at Garden Grove Elementary School (Case No. 2024CUPP033684). The suit says adults had been warned about the boy. Afterward, it says, the school kept him on campus while the 5-year-old was walked to class and ate lunch alone with her teacher to avoid him.
The principal first told the parents that security video matched the girl's account closely enough to report it to child protective services, the suit says. Later, the principal wrote that the video showed nothing more than the two children in the same area. By then, the suit says, the footage had been recorded over, though the parents had asked that it be saved. The family calls that evidence of "a cover up." The suit also says the school's resource officer wrote her report without watching the video and did not collect it because she never planned to arrest the boy. That summer, according to the suit, the park district accepted the boy into its summer camp as a "counselor-in-training."
In June, a judge ordered the park district and its lawyer to pay $1,750 in sanctions for improperly instructing a witness not to answer questions, including what the witness knew about the alleged assault.
A middle school girl. A Sinaloa Middle School student says a classmate groped her at least 10 times in class beginning in August 2025 and pulled her hair so hard she had bald patches (Case No. 2026CUPP067419). Her parents reported it to school administrators and the police. The suit says the school never investigated and a Title IX investigator never finished.
“Not really a Title IX matter.” A Simi Valley High School student in special education says she and her parents reported sexual harassment at least eight times in 2023 and 2024 (Case No. 2025CUCR054429). In one episode, she says, about 15 boys surrounded her, and one said he wanted to sexually assault her. The school disciplined her for hitting one of the boys as she tried to get away but did not discipline the boys, the suit says. The principal and an assistant superintendent told her parents it was "not really a Title IX matter," according to the suit. Her parents moved her to another district.
An older claim against a teacher. A man says a sixth-grade teacher at Garden Grove sexually abused him in 2011 and 2012, before Ms. Smollen joined the board (Case No. 2025CUPP041250).
Special Education Claims and a Reported $6.8 Million Settlement
Ms. Smollen, the mother of three graduates of Simi Valley schools, two of them daughters, has pointed to her own family's experience with special education. Her district biography says one of her children had a special education plan and that the experience helps her understand what other families face. Besides the high school student's case, two more involve special education students.
A former aide says a teacher at Santa Susana Elementary School screamed in the face of a nonverbal autistic student and mocked children for humming and rocking (Case No. 2026CUOE065252). She says she was let go the next working day after filing a second complaint. The case is in arbitration.
In 2019, the families of 10 special education students sued over a teacher at Garden Grove and Sycamore elementary schools. They said she grabbed, dragged and dropped children as young as 5, most of whom could not speak (Case No. 56-2019-00528970). The teacher denied the allegations. In February 2021, during Ms. Smollen's first term, a $6.8 million settlement was proposed, the Ventura County Star reported. The case was dismissed that April.
Two federal lawsuits are also pending: one by a former employee against the district and its superintendent, who denies her claims (Case No. 2:26-cv-05712), and one filed Oct. 9 by a family identified only by initials.
No Campus Officers, and Raises for Top Administrators
In 2022, Ms. Smollen called for more school resource officers on campuses. Yet for part of the 2025-26 school year, none were assigned to the district's 28 schools. The city assigns and pays the officers, and a City Council member, not the school board, proposed a working group on the shortage.
The board's main lever over how staff handle abuse reports is the superintendent, whom it hires, evaluates and pays. In June 2025, while the 5-year-old's lawsuit was pending, Ms. Smollen moved or seconded raises of about $6,000 to $8,300 a year for two of his top deputies, according to board minutes.
Falling Scores, and the Widest Gaps for Latino and Black Students
In 2016, before Ms. Smollen joined the board, about 54 percent of Simi Valley students met state standards in English and 42 percent in math, about five points above the state in each. On the 2025-26 tests, released Oct. 15, the district's figures were 50.3 percent and 37.3 percent, compared with 49.3 and 38.4 percent statewide. The state has climbed back to its 2016 levels since the pandemic. Simi Valley has not.
How Simi Valley students did on the 2025-26 state tests
Share of students who met or exceeded state standards, with the statewide figure in parentheses:
Latino students: 38.3 percent in English (39.6) and 24.9 percent in math (27.0).
Black students: 42.5 percent in English (33.7) and 25.5 percent in math (21.5).
White students: 58.0 percent in English (61.7) and 44.2 percent in math (51.4).
Asian students: 73.5 percent in English (73.4) and 68.5 percent in math (70.5).
Source: California Department of Education results, compiled by EdSource.
The gaps are widest for Latino students, who make up more than 40 percent of enrollment. In spring 2018, months before Ms. Smollen took office, about 41 percent of Latino students met the English standard and 28 percent met the math standard. This year, 38 percent and 25 percent did. That leaves them about 20 points behind white students in each subject and below Latino students statewide. Black students' scores fell from about 49 percent to 42 percent in English and from 30 percent to 25 percent in math, leaving them 15 to 19 points behind white classmates. They still outscored Black students statewide, but they make up only about 1.5 percent of enrollment, so their results can swing from year to year.
Those declines came while Ms. Smollen served on the board, including two turns as its president. The board does not run classrooms, but it adopts the district's yearly plan for raising achievement and hires and evaluates the superintendent who carries it out. The plan the board adopted in 2025 acknowledged that English scores for several groups of students remained below the district's targets.
Such gaps are not unique to Simi Valley Unified. Melissa Valenzuela-Stookey, research director at EdTrust-West, an education equity group, said this year's statewide results show "glaring gaps in outcomes for Black and Latino students." Still, statewide, Black and Latino students gained more ground this year than white and Asian students, and Black students have climbed past their prepandemic scores, EdSource reported. In Simi Valley, Black students' scores fell about four points in each subject from the year before and remain well below where they were before the pandemic.
Deficits, Cuts and a Superintendent's Warning
The district's finances have also weakened during Ms. Smollen's tenure, and its own superintendent, Hani Youssef, has warned trustees about it. Enrollment has fallen from about 17,600 students a decade ago to about 15,000, and state funding follows students. In August, Dr. Youssef told the board that the district now graduates more seniors than it enrolls in kindergarten.
The district expected to spend $7 million to $8 million more than it took in during 2025-26, according to its midyear budget reports. In June, the board, led by Ms. Smollen, unanimously approved a budget that plans another deficit of about $4.4 million and cuts 15 teaching positions. The district's fund balance is expected to fall from about $54 million to about $44 million over two years.
Trustees also did not place a facilities bond on the November ballot. Dr. Youssef warned that going without one would create "very difficult financial challenges."
What's at Stake for the Park District
If she wins, Ms. Smollen would join the board of one defendant in the 5-year-old's case weeks before trial, after eight years on the board of the other. As a director, she could vote in closed session on how the park district handles that lawsuit, including any settlement, and on any future claims that children were harmed in its programs. She would also help set the rules for its after-school clubs, including how staff supervise children and report abuse allegations, the same policies at the center of the case.
Ms. Smollen points to her school board work on budgets and on agreements for shared use of school and park facilities. Her opponent, Mary Northrup, a certified municipal clerk, is campaigning on accountability and transparency.
The question for voters is whether Ms. Smollen, as a park director, would demand that the park district enforce safety measures for the children and families who use its programs.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
