Simi Valley Schools Lost Ground on Dawn Smollen’s Watch. Will the Park District Suffer the Same Fate?
In her eight years on the school board, enrollment and test scores fell and at least four abuse suits were filed, and the district is now spending down its savings. Her board approved two raises for the superintendent and announced no action on an abuse suit naming top officials. In December 2026, she is set to represent Division 2 on the Rancho Simi park board, which faces strains of its own in money, leadership and children’s safety.
FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSEDUCATIONRANCHO SIMI VALLEY PARK DISTRICTOPINION


SIMI VALLEY, Calif.
Dawn Smollen is leaving the Simi Valley Unified School District (SVUSD) board after eight years, the most its term limits allow. She leaves a district that is, by several measures, worse off than the one she joined. It has about 1,400 fewer students. Its test scores are lower than when she joined and far behind its neighbors’. It is drawing on savings for a second straight year. And at least four lawsuits accuse it of failing to protect students from sexual abuse or harassment during her years on the board.
Ms. Smollen sat on the board that hired the district’s superintendent and presided over his latest raise.
In December 2026, Ms. Smollen is expected to join the Rancho Simi Recreation and Park District board. In the county’s Nov. 12, 2026, count, she leads Mary Northrup by more than 15 percentage points for the Division 2 seat. The results are not yet certified.
A park board, like a school board, sets the budget, hires and oversees a top manager, and answers for the safety of children in its programs. The park district is not in crisis. It has reserves and steady property tax money. But it faces strains in all three areas. Its savings are set to fall by more than half. Its manager of eight years retired in August 2026, months after a complaint about his conduct, which he disputed. And it is a defendant in a lawsuit over the alleged sexual assault of a young SVUSD student in one of its after-school clubs, a case it shares with the school district.
Ms. Smollen did not respond to requests for comment, including several about Superintendent Hani Youssef and Assistant Superintendent Sean Goldman being named in a student-on-student abuse suit. In Nov. 12, 2026, comments on Facebook, she faulted The Ledger for earlier posting court papers in that suit that showed the student’s name, calling it “a serious disregard for a child’s right to privacy.” The Ledger has since replaced the papers with redacted copies. She wrote that such cases belong “with the appropriate legal authorities and the courts.” Neither comment said what the board has done to keep students safe.
The Record Dawn Smollen Leaves at SVUSD
Test scores. In spring 2019, months after Ms. Smollen joined the board, 54 percent of Simi Valley students met state English standards and 43 percent met math standards. Both rates were about 3 points above the state’s. In 2026, about 50 percent met English standards and 37 percent met math standards, up slightly since 2024. Statewide, 49 percent met English standards and 38 percent met math standards. Scores fell across California in those years, but Simi Valley’s fell further: about 4 points in English and 6 in math, compared with about 2 points and 1 point statewide. That leaves half of Simi Valley’s students short in English and 63 percent short in math. Even the state’s rate leaves most students behind: across California, 62 percent of students also fall short in math.
Nearby districts score far higher:
Oak Park Unified had 79 percent meeting English standards and 72 percent meeting math standards in 2026.
Conejo Valley Unified, in Thousand Oaks, is about Simi Valley’s size. In 2026, 66 percent met English standards and 56 percent met math standards, about 16 points higher in English and 19 in math.
Las Virgenes Unified had 70 percent meeting English standards and 61 percent meeting math standards in 2026.
Enrollment and money. About 16,450 students attended district schools in 2018-19, when Ms. Smollen joined the board. By 2025-26, enrollment had fallen to about 15,100, part of a slide that began in the mid-2000s. Only 860 kindergartners enrolled in fall 2026, down from just over 900 in fall 2025. Officials describe the district’s finances as stable, and its reserves remain above the state’s required minimum. But in March 2026, the district projected that the 2025-26 budget would cut its savings by about $8 million. And in June 2026, with Ms. Smollen as president, the board unanimously approved a $255 million budget that runs a deficit of about $4.4 million and cuts 15 teaching positions, mostly through retirements and expiring temporary contracts.
Abuse lawsuits. Court records show at least four abuse suits from her years on the board, plus a criminal case against a coach. The three most recent suits are pending and have not gone to trial, and the claims against the district are unproven.
Sinaloa Middle School, 2025. A student was physically and sexually assaulted by a classmate in class, starting in August 2025, the suit says. The suit names the district, Dr. Youssef, Mr. Goldman, Principal Shawn Rumble and Assistant Principal Mandy Hardin. The district, Mr. Goldman and the two school administrators have denied the claims; court records through Nov. 5, 2026, show no response yet from Dr. Youssef. None of the defendants responded to The Ledger’s requests for comment on the suit.
Garden Grove Elementary, 2024. A young SVUSD student was sexually assaulted by an older student in the park district’s after-school club on campus, the suit says. Trial is set for Jan. 15, 2027, but all parties have asked the judge to delay it by at least 90 days.
Simi Valley High School, 2023-24. The plaintiffs say their child faced repeated sexual harassment and bullying from other students, and that the school failed to act on at least eight reports.
Simi Valley High School, 2019. A former student was sexually abused as a teenager by Bijan Nickroo, a coach at the school, the suit says. Mr. Nickroo later pleaded no contest to 35 counts and was sentenced to five years in state prison.
Simi Valley High School, 2025. In a separate criminal case, the police arrested Jabari DeShields, then 36, an assistant walk-on boys basketball coach at the school, on Nov. 6, 2025. The district said it had hired him that school year. Prosecutors charged him with five counts of lewd acts on a child involving two 14-year-olds, and he pleaded not guilty on Nov. 10, 2025. The case is pending. The police said he met the two at a local business outside school hours. Both were enrolled in the district at the time, the police said, but neither attended Simi Valley High. The district said at the time that he was on leave.
Three of the four suits involve attacks or harassment by other students. Sinaloa and Garden Grove each had a state-required safety plan with clear rules on paper. Sinaloa’s plan says all staff are mandated reporters and that “all reports will be investigated by the site Title IX administrator.” Garden Grove’s plan required staff to report student sexual harassment to the principal or a district compliance officer within one school day. Its cover page lists Erin Taggart, then the district’s director of elementary education, as approving it on Nov. 2, 2023.
The plaintiffs say the schools did not follow through. The Sinaloa suit says administrators did not report repeated assaults, and the Garden Grove plaintiff says the older student kept coming into contact with the younger student after the parents complained.
The district’s own documents also show gaps in follow-through. Sinaloa’s 2025-26 plan contradicts itself on whether the prior year’s safety goals were evaluated: one page says an evaluation took place in December 2024, and another says none was completed because the plan’s format was new.
A new state law required school safety plans to include, by July 1, 2026, procedures to protect children from abuse and sex offenses. Board records show two related votes. On May 19, 2026, the board voted 5-0, with Ms. Smollen in favor, to update its policy on adult-student conduct to reflect the law. On Sept. 8, 2026, it voted 4-0, again with Ms. Smollen in favor and Trustee Ron Resnick absent, to approve the 2026-27 safety plans for every school. Sinaloa’s 2026-27 plan says the district is “currently developing” the procedures.
A special education settlement. An older case against the district was also settled during Ms. Smollen’s tenure on the board of trustees. In 2019, plaintiffs acting for children in a Garden Grove Elementary special education class sued, saying the teacher had grabbed, dragged and dropped children as young as 5. The suit also named Mr. Goldman. The teacher, who left the district in 2018, denied the claims, and the district denied any cover-up. A judge approved the settlement in March 2021.
A federal civil rights suit. The district also faces a federal lawsuit filed Oct. 9, 2026, by the parents of a 10-year-old disabled student at Atherwood Elementary. The suit says school staff took away the tablet the student uses to speak in February 2026. It says the principal, Shay Lundstrom, acting at Mr. Goldman’s direction, kept the student in her office with the door closed and refused requests to call home. Mr. Goldman later wrote that the principal “was properly implementing the District’s cell phone policy,” the suit says. The suit names the district, Mr. Goldman, Ms. Lundstrom and a teacher. The claims are unproven.
Raises. The board hires, evaluates and sets the pay of the superintendent. Dr. Youssef has led the district since July 2022.
His pay. Dr. Youssef’s base pay rose from about $292,800 in 2024 to about $304,400 in 2025, public pay records show.
2025. On June 10, 2025, with Ms. Smollen as the board’s clerk, the board voted 4-1 to approve a new contract for Dr. Youssef with a raise of $11,899.77. Ms. Smollen voted yes. Dr. Youssef told the board the raises reflected the step increases that all employees receive.
2026. On June 9, 2026, with Ms. Smollen presiding, the board voted 5-0 to approve another raise for Dr. Youssef, this one $18,814.55. At the same meeting, it gave Mr. Goldman a raise of $11,836.70, the same month he was named in the Sinaloa suit.
Is the Rancho Simi Park District Next?
Board actions and court records show a park district already under strain.
Its budget is tightening. In June 2026, the board gave early approval to a $68 million budget for 2026-27, and the district’s total balance is expected to fall from about $44 million to $17 million as it pays for big projects.
Its leadership has also turned over. In October 2025, an Oak Park resident complained about how Dan Paranick, then the district manager, acted at a political event in Moorpark. Mr. Paranick called it a misunderstanding. The board met behind closed doors and reported no action, and he took several weeks of leave. In March 2026, he announced he would retire Aug. 1, 2026, and the board approved a backdated 3.5 percent raise for him. Ed Abele, whose seat Ms. Smollen is set to take, was the only board member to oppose it, saying the manager’s contract did not tie ethics violations to firing. The district has since hired Steve Wright to replace Mr. Paranick.
In the Garden Grove suit, a judge in June 2026 ordered the park district and its lawyer to pay $1,750 for improperly blocking a witness’s answers.
Ms. Smollen’s school board record bears on two of those strains. Both boards raised their top leader’s pay during hard times. The difference came after complaints. The park manager went on leave within weeks of one. At the school district, Dr. Youssef, Mr. Goldman and the two Sinaloa administrators are defendants in an abuse suit and remain in their jobs. Agendas and minutes of the board, led by Ms. Smollen, list no action on the suit since it was filed in June 2026, though two recent agendas list closed sessions on unnamed legal matters. The claims are unproven, and the district denies them.
The Garden Grove case raises a more direct question. Ms. Smollen served on one defendant’s board and is set to join the other’s. It is not clear whether she will sit in on the park board’s closed-door talks about the case.
What She Says, and What Comes Next
During the campaign, Ms. Smollen said she would focus on keeping up existing parks, protecting open space and spending carefully. She also called for closer work among the park district, the school district, the city and the police to improve safety.
The kind of partnership Ms. Smollen has proposed is at the heart of the Garden Grove case. Her campaign website points to joint-use agreements between the two districts and lists park district before- and after-school programs on school campuses, including Garden Grove’s. The suit says both agencies knew, or should have known, that the older student had a history of touching younger students. It also says the younger student’s parents asked school resource officer Amanda Torres, a Simi Valley police officer, to save security video of the assault. Officer Torres allegedly wrote her report without watching it, and the suit says the camera system later recorded over it. Neither she nor the Police Department is a defendant. She declined to comment on Oct. 21, 2026.
Whenever the Garden Grove trial begins, the park district she is set to join and the school district she is leaving will sit on the same side of the courtroom, answering the plaintiff’s claim that a young SVUSD student was assaulted in a program the two districts shared.
If the results hold, Ms. Smollen’s park board term will run four years, to December 2030. By then, voters will be able to judge the park district by the same measures this story has applied to the schools: its savings, its leadership and the safety of the children in its programs. She leaves a school district with about 1,400 fewer students than when she joined, lower test scores, a budget that draws on savings and at least four abuse suits from her tenure. The question for park district voters is whether the park district she leaves in 2030 will look like the school district she is leaving now.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
