Simi Valley's $166 Million Town Center Mall Failed. Now the City Must Choose: Up to 996 Homes, or a Pleasant Place to Live
The owners of Simi Valley's struggling Town Center want to build hundreds of homes there. Many residents oppose the plan, and some want something else: open space and a place to play that could draw visitors from across the region.
FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSCOMMUNITYOPINION


SIMI VALLEY, Calif. — When the Simi Valley Town Center opened in the fall of 2005, it was billed as the first new regional shopping center in Ventura County in more than 25 years. Designed to look like a hillside Italian village, it opened with 120 tenants and two department stores.
Twenty-one years later, the mall has been an overwhelming failure. It cost about $166 million to build and sold in 2024 for about $38 million. It has lost every department store, and its roster has shrunk to 67 stores.
Even Apple, one of the world's most successful retailers, closed its store there in 2017. If a company that big would not stay, small local businesses face even longer odds.
Now the city faces a choice. The mall's new owners want to replace part of it with high-density housing. Many residents oppose that plan. Some would rather see the site become what the mall never was: a place where families from Simi Valley and nearby towns come to swim, ride, play and gather. From a swim lake in Los Angeles to a BMX track in South Carolina, other cities have shown that kind of place can work.
What's Happening
The Plan
The owners, SteelWave and Steerpoint Capital, filed an early site plan with the city in February 2025. It would:
Build 291 to 375 homes on about 15.75 acres, roughly a third of the site. That is 18 to 24 homes per acre. Simi Valley's high-density category tops out at 20, so the owners asked to rezone the land for high- and very-high-density housing. The city's low- and medium-density zones allow about 2 to 5 homes per acre.
Open the door to more. Under state density bonus laws, the owners could build as many as 996 homes if they set aside some as affordable.
Tear down about 312,000 of the mall's roughly 594,000 square feet, cutting retail space about in half.
Gregg Hall, a managing director at SteelWave, told the City Council that the Town Center was planned as a traditional mall two decades ago and that shopping has changed dramatically since. "Reducing obsolete space boosts traffic and tax revenue," he said. Glen Becerra, who served on the council from 1998 to 2018, has worked as a consultant for the owners.
Who Decides
The plan cannot move forward unless the City Council agrees to amend the city's General Plan and change the zoning. In May 2025, the council voted 4 to 1 to let SteelWave apply for those changes. That vote approved nothing, and City Manager Samantha Argabrite has said the council can still deny the project.
That gives the city leverage. It could require open space, a recreation attraction or a public gathering place as a condition of any approval. Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh has already said the homes should not go up before the shopping center is improved.
Timing matters. Once land is zoned for housing, state laws make it much harder for cities to block projects that follow the rules. Council member Rocky Rhodes asked for a firm cap on homes because he feared the city could lose its power to say no.
The city's power has limits. It cannot force the owners to build a surf park. And a 2024 state law, AB 2243, lets owners of some regional malls build mixed-income housing without a rezoning vote. The Town Center appears to meet the law's basic test for a regional mall, which includes a site under 100 acres and at least 250,000 square feet of retail. But a project would have to meet strict rules on affordable units and construction wages, plus limits on block sizes and open space. So far, SteelWave has asked the city for a rezoning instead.
What Comes Next
The May 2025 vote gave SteelWave one year to file a full application. That window ended in May, but in August a local real estate firm still described the project as in the pre-application stage. The Ledger could not find a public record showing that a full application has been filed. If one is, the project must still pass an environmental review and win another council vote. Voters choose a mayor and three council members today, and the winners will help decide the Town Center's future.
Why It Matters
What 375 Homes Would Mean
By the Ledger's estimate, using Census figures and standard traffic rates, 375 homes would bring:
About 1,050 new residents, if households match the city's average of 2.81 people per home. At 996 homes, that would rise to about 2,800.
About 2,000 to 2,700 new car trips a day, based on standard traffic engineering rates for apartments and townhomes. That includes roughly 165 to 210 cars in the evening rush hour, likely on First Street, Erringer Road and the 118 ramps.
Taller buildings. In 2023, city code limited very-high-density zones to three stories, or about 40 feet, and the city's housing plan called for allowing four. Council member Elaine Litster has raised concerns about hillside views.
A big share of the state's housing target. The homes equal about 13 percent of the 2,793 homes the state expects Simi Valley to plan for by 2029.
Residents near the site would also live through a build-out that a Steerpoint official said could take five or six years, and could lose two museums: the Skateboarding Hall of Fame and a military history museum. If the owners use state density bonus rules, required parking could shrink, pushing cars onto nearby streets. By the Ledger's estimate, a busy mall would bring even more traffic: nearly 12,000 trips a day if the space slated for demolition were fully leased. But only about half the mall was leased in 2025.
Residents Push Back
The plan would reverse city policy. Simi Valley left the Town Center out of its 2021-2029 housing plan on purpose, to keep it as a regional hub. Litster, the lone no vote, said the plan seemed out of step with what residents want.
Many residents agree. For years, they have packed public meetings to fight state pressure for dense apartment buildings. At the May 2025 hearing, several speakers objected to the number of homes, citing traffic, lost sales tax money and the permanent loss of commercial land. Even the mall's general manager, Jeff DeJulius, who supports the owners, said there was "no reason to go high density at the mall."
Housing has supporters, too. California is short on homes, and one resident told the council that affordable housing helps create community. In 2022, then-Mayor Keith Mashburn said the market showed strong demand for dense housing, even though "many people say they don't want high-density housing."
The Other Option
Some residents and officials want the site to become a regional playground. Bob Cottle, a former city planner, told the council he opposes high-density housing there and wants recreation or entertainment uses explored first. Council member Joseph Ayala asked the owners for a master plan with public amenities such as a pool, open space and community areas.
The site sits off the 118, a short drive from the San Fernando Valley, Moorpark and Thousand Oaks. It could hold a swim lake, a pump track and BMX course, a lawn for concerts and movie nights, or an indoor dirt bike arena inside an empty department store.
It would also fill a local gap. Simi Valley's dirt BMX track, Sycamore BMX, closed in February 2019, and apartments now stand on the site. In March 2026, the council passed rules that ban stunts like wheelies on sidewalks and paths. The rules say where riders cannot do stunts, but not where they can.
A resort carries real risks. Big attractions are costly and slow to build, and they need an operator willing to invest. One desert surf park had mechanical problems in its early months and drew dozens of noise complaints.
The Big Picture
A Mall That Never Worked
After just five years, the original owner sold the mall. Macy's closed one of its two stores in 2017, the center fell into default on its loans in 2019, according to documents reported at the time, and Macy's closed its last store in 2024.
The site itself works against shoppers. An earlier owner said the mall had "zero visibility" from the 118 and that new stores would not move in without digital signs along the freeway. When the movie theater opened, a real estate broker predicted it would draw Simi Valley residents but not shoppers from nearby cities.
Places That Chose to Play
In Lake View Terrace, Los Angeles built a 1.5-acre swim lake behind Hansen Dam. It is often called the largest public pool in the country. Adults pay $4, children pay $1, and the city hosts free movie nights by the water.
In Placer County, the Planning Commission voted unanimously in September to approve the Alchemy Surf Resort, a 25-acre project with a five-acre surf lagoon and a 100-room hotel. In Palm Desert, the city agreed in 2019 to sell land at its own golf resort for $2 million, and the DSRT Surf lagoon began opening to the public in September.
In Virginia Beach, Va., a city-owned lot sat empty for nearly 30 years before a $350 million partnership began turning it into a district with a surf lagoon, a music venue, shops and apartments. The lagoon opened in August 2025.
Rock Hill, S.C., opened an Olympic-level BMX track in 2014, paid for with a local tax on restaurant food and drinks. Its 2017 world championships drew 3,700 riders from 48 countries and an estimated $19.2 million in direct spending. Closer to home, riders and bike companies raised $1.2 million for a pump track in Inglewood, and Thousand Oaks has the free Sapwi Bike Park. In Scotland, an indoor arena called iMotoX fits three electric dirt bike tracks into about 49,000 square feet.
Paying for a Different Future
Simi Valley does not own the land. The last sale price of about $38 million equals almost 40 percent of the city's roughly $100 million general fund. Still, the city could borrow through lease revenue bonds without a public vote or use a special financing district that repays debt with growth in property tax revenue.
The city could also sell part of the site for fewer homes to help pay for open space and recreation. Irvine did something similar: taxes on thousands of new homes helped pay for its Orange County Great Park.
A Glimpse of What Could Be
In October, the Town Center gave away free pumpkins and hosted Spooky Town, its yearly Halloween party.
Those nights offer a glimpse of what the site could be: a place where Simi Valley and its neighbors gather. The question now is whether that future holds hundreds of new homes, a regional place to play, or some mix of both.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
