The Churchill Simi Valley Is Pre-Leasing From $2,600 a Month. Not Everyone in Simi Valley Is Thrilled.
Rents at the first of two four-story buildings planned at Heywood and Erringer start above the city's median. Neighbors opposed the second over traffic, safety and height, but state law leaves the city little room to say no.
FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSCOMMUNITYOPINION


What's Happening
SIMI VALLEY, Calif. — The Churchill, a four-story, 91-unit apartment building on Heywood Street, has begun pre-leasing. Not everyone is thrilled. Even its cheapest market-rate apartment costs more than the city's median rent, according to recent Census figures. Neighbors have also objected to a second four-story building planned next door, citing traffic, safety and size.
For years, the lot at 1850 Heywood Street, just west of Erringer Road, held little more than parked cars. A medical building there had been torn down. "It's been sitting there dormant ever since," Adrian Stern, managing partner of developer Heywood Street Associates, said in 2022. Now the building's website, under the slogan "Built Without Shortcuts," is taking applications. City records list Chris Itule as the company's manager on the project.
As of Oct. 30, the building's application portal listed one-bedrooms from $2,600 a month and two-bedrooms up to $3,250. It showed 85 of the 91 apartments as available, with a $500 deposit and 12-month leases. Three "affordable" floor plans appeared at $1,000 a month, marked "coming soon." Apartments.com lists a $50 application fee and estimates that a household needs about $104,000 a year to qualify for the cheapest unit.
The project has grown since the Planning Commission unanimously recommended it in November 2022. Back then, it was planned as an 83-unit, $35 million building with 131 parking spaces, a pool and a gym. A May 2024 city staff memo described 91 units, five of them affordable. The developer was also asking the city for a loan of up to $1 million to help finish the building. Staff recommended approving the loan. The records reviewed for this article refer to amended versions of the project's housing agreement but do not say when the extra units were approved.
The building also ran late. In May 2024, it was reported to be almost complete, and a month later it was expected to be finished that summer. Rents came in above the developer's early estimates, too. At a neighborhood council meeting in September 2022, the developer predicted about $1,800 to $2,200 a month for one-bedrooms and $2,100 to $2,300 for two-bedrooms. Today the cheapest one-bedroom is $400 above the top of that range, and two-bedrooms run $875 to $950 above theirs.
The Churchill is the first of two four-story buildings Heywood Street Associates has planned at Heywood and Erringer. The second, the 66-unit Ridge, won City Council approval in 2024, even though the local neighborhood council recommended denying it. To critics, the pair shows how state housing laws are reshaping a suburb where nearly three in four households own their homes. That change often comes over local objections.
Why It Matters
From a Quiet Approval to a 7-2 "No"
The Churchill itself drew little opposition. When Neighborhood Council No. 3 reviewed it in September 2022, residents asked about rents and whether tenants would come from out of town. The council recommended approval. Coverage of the Planning Commission hearing that November mentioned no public objections.
The Ridge was different. In January 2024, the same council questioned the developer's traffic study and asked about guest parking and the Churchill next door. It then voted 7 to 2 to recommend denial, citing traffic and height. Residents spoke up at the Planning Commission that May. Steve Capp and Adrian Stuck argued that more cars would mean more danger for children and people on foot. Commissioner Ivana Mayer cast the only no vote. She pointed to parking and to two four-story buildings standing close together.
A Busy Corner Gets Busier
Erringer Road already has a troubled record. Simi Valley police counted 687 crashes citywide in 2023, up from 670 the year before, and deadly crashes doubled to 10. Three of the intersections police named as most crash-prone are on Erringer, at Los Angeles Avenue, Royal Avenue and Cochran Street. The city has since approved signals at Royal and Cochran that allow left turns only on a green arrow.
The city's environmental review reached a calmer conclusion. It estimated that the Churchill would add about 559 car trips a day to a stretch of Heywood Street that carries about 2,300. That is an increase of roughly one-fourth. The review noted that the added trips would not double traffic and found the effect was not significant. All traffic uses one driveway on Heywood, which city traffic engineers said met local standards. Firefighters from Station 41, 1.8 miles away, could still meet the department's five-minute goal. For the Ridge, city staff accepted the developer's traffic study, which found no significant increase. That building would have no exit onto Heywood, the developer said.
Overall, Simi Valley does better than most cities its size. The California Office of Traffic Safety counted 445 people killed or hurt in crashes there in 2023. That ranked it 40th of 62 cities with 100,000 to 250,000 people, where No. 1 is the worst. Nineteen of the victims were pedestrians, three of them under 15. Children at the Churchill would be assigned to Berylwood Elementary, on the same street, at 2300 Heywood.
The site carried another risk. It sat in a federally mapped flood zone, and the city required an updated flood map before grading could begin.
More Height, Fewer Trees
The Churchill got its extra height through the state's density bonus law. Under the 2022 plan, the developer agreed to rent about 5 percent of the units to very low-income tenants. In return, it could add a fourth story above the city's three-story limit and reach 45 feet 6 inches instead of 40. The landscaping strip along Heywood shrank from 10 feet to just over five. Forty of the 44 mature trees on the site were slated for removal, with large replacement trees required, the environmental review shows.
The building's website calls its design contemporary. Its amenities feel more big-city than suburban. They include a movie theater, a library, a shared workspace and keyless entry through a Verkada security system. Some apartments are two-story, townhome-style units. Medical offices sit across Heywood to the north, and a senior apartment building is to the west. To the south are the Arroyo Simi trail and Rancho Simi Community Park.
The fourth story sits at the back, away from Heywood, and the review found the building would not greatly change the area's look. In 2022, Commissioner Tim Hodge said he appreciated that the developer asked for less density and height than the project was allowed. Commissioner Dawn Gray praised the modern design. The project has since grown by eight units.
The Ridge drew sharper design complaints. Mr. Capp told the Planning Commission it would clash with nearby homes. Mr. Stuck worried that four-story buildings would block views of the hills. At the City Council in June 2024, critics asked for a more Mediterranean design. Councilmember Elaine Litster voted no, citing the project's height, look and size beside the Arroyo Simi.
Mr. Stern said he was aware of the concerns about size. He pointed to colors and architectural details, heavy landscaping and a ban on parking along Erringer in front of the building. He described the project as denser and more urban, like developments in Warner Center in the San Fernando Valley. Sean Gibson, the city's deputy environmental services director, said staff had worked hard with the developer to improve the design. But he added that "design is in the eye of the beholder."
Who Can Afford It
Renters will need steady paychecks. A common rule says rent should take no more than 30 percent of income, and Apartments.com uses it for its estimates. By that rule, a $3,000 apartment calls for an income of about $120,000 a year. The Churchill's two-bedrooms, at $3,175 to $3,250, would take about $127,000 to $130,000. Some landlords use a looser test: monthly income of three times the rent. By that test, a $3,000 apartment would need about $108,000.
Simi Valley's median household income falls between those marks. It was $117,703 in Census estimates for 2019 through 2023. The same figures put the city's median rent at $2,513. The Churchill's cheapest market-rate unit rents for a bit more than that, and its two-bedrooms for about $650 to $750 more. The real gap is wider, because the Census figure includes utilities and the Churchill's listed rents do not.
In 2022, Mr. Stern said the building would appeal to millennials or to people who could not afford other places to live. Most tenants will likely be small households: 59 of the 85 units listed as available on Oct. 30 were one-bedrooms. The website says the 118 Freeway puts residents in the San Fernando Valley within minutes, and it points to the Metrolink line to Los Angeles. But the developer also said that about 80 percent of tenants at its two other nearby buildings already had Simi Valley addresses.
In population terms, the building is small. The environmental review used two figures, 2.2 and 2.98 people per apartment. By those measures, the Churchill would house 200 to 270 people, roughly two-tenths of 1 percent of the city. Federal estimates put Simi Valley at about 125,100 residents in mid-2023, down from 126,356 in 2020.
The city's 2022 review found that schools and parks could absorb the newcomers. Simi Valley Unified had 15,081 students in the 2025-26 school year, down from 16,436 in 2019. The developer estimated that the building would bring in about $97,000 a year in property taxes.
The Big Picture
Much of what neighbors object to is out of the city's hands. The state's density bonus law lets developers who include affordable units build more homes than local rules allow. It also lets them skip some local limits, such as on height. The Ridge got its fourth story that way. Another state law, the Housing Accountability Act, goes further. To reject or shrink such a project, a city must prove a serious, measurable threat to health or safety. That threat must be judged by clear written rules. The city must also show there is no other workable fix.
Simi Valley has run into those limits before. In December 2019, the Planning Commission rejected a four-story, 278-unit project at Tapo and Alamo streets after neighbors objected. The state housing department then sent the city three letters warning that the denial could break state law. If the city held firm, the state could pull its approval of the city's housing plan. That could expose Simi Valley to lawsuits, fines and the loss of state money, and even cost it some control over its own permits. The commission reversed itself in early 2020, and the City Council approved the project that November. "We do need the housing, there's no doubt about it," Mayor Keith Mashburn said at the time.
At the Ridge hearing, Ms. Mayer argued that commissioners should stand by their convictions, even if it meant trouble with the state. She was outvoted.
The Churchill's five low-income apartments are a small part of what the state expects. Under a regional target set by the Southern California Association of Governments, Simi Valley must plan for 2,793 new homes between 2021 and 2029. Of those, 1,242 are meant for very low- and low-income households. The Churchill covers about 3 percent of the total and well under 1 percent of the lower-income share. The other 86 apartments rent at market rates.
The Test Ahead
For now, the Churchill is courting renters. On Oct. 30, a pop-up on its website offered a free first month with a 14-month lease. To get it, renters had to apply within 24 hours of seeing a unit. Those who applied within a week could get half off the first rent payment, and the pop-up also mentioned military and veteran discounts. The fine print said restrictions apply and other costs and fees are not included. The offer did not appear on the Apartments.com listing or the application portal.
Next door sits the approved site of the Ridge. Whether the two buildings settle quietly into the neighborhood or prove their critics right will become clear in the years ahead. The answer will show up in the parking lots, at the crosswalks and along Heywood Street.
The worry was on the record from the start. When the Churchill was first presented to the neighborhood council in 2022, a resident in the audience said the timing was poor. The city, the resident said, lacked the power and water for more building.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
