Where Other Cities Stumbled, Simi Valley Has Gotten Flock Cameras Right
As cities pause or drop Flock's license plate cameras, Simi Valley police point to stolen-car arrests, weekly audits and no reported misuse. Critics cite a vendor error and results the city has never published.
FEATUREDSIMI VALLEY NEWSCOMMUNITYSIMI VALLEY POLITICSOPINION


Amid a national uproar over Flock Safety's license plate cameras, Simi Valley stands out for how well it has managed its own.
No misuse by a local officer has been reported. The police department audits searches weekly, keeps data for 30 days and blocks queries tied to immigration or reproductive care. When a vendor error came to light in February, it audited more than two years of records and disclosed what it found: two federal searches, both tied to criminal cases.
The cameras also keep producing results. At 1:37 a.m. on Thursday, Oct. 29, one of them flagged a car reported stolen in Los Angeles County three days earlier. An officer stopped it on Erringer Road and arrested the driver, a Simi Valley woman, on suspicion of driving a stolen vehicle and possessing a controlled substance.
That record contrasts with trouble elsewhere. Los Angeles police let their Flock contract lapse, Oxnard suspended its cameras and officers in other states were accused of using them to track former partners.
Questions remain. The city has never published how many arrests the cameras have produced, and research has not settled how much they help. Here is what the cameras record, what they have been shown to do and how residents can weigh in.
How the Cameras Got Here
The City Council approved the cameras unanimously in May 2023, buying 23 readers under a four-year contract capped at $238,050 and paid for with forfeited assets. Councilmember Elaine Litster noted residents' privacy worries at the time, while Councilmember Dee Dee Cavanaugh said she trusted the department to use the system well. Monitoring began that November. Ahead of a January 2024 public forum, Mayor Fred Thomas told the Acorn the system was “a crime-fighting tool and that's all it is.”
Police told the council in April that the department controls 26 cameras, including three portable units. Six more came through a sheriff's grant aimed at retail theft.
What the Cameras Record, and What They Don't
The cameras photograph vehicles, not people. Each image records a car's plate, make, model and color, features like bumper stickers, and the time and place, according to the department's 2023 description. They take no video or audio and use no facial recognition, police told the council in April, and the department says it never sells the data.
Officers are alerted when a plate on a “hot list” of stolen or wanted vehicles passes a camera, and a person must confirm the match before they act. Every search must list a reason and is logged.
Other California agencies can be granted access to Simi Valley's data. A resident told the council in April that more than 100 agencies have it.
The Case for the Cameras
Police say about seven in 10 crimes involve a vehicle, so a plate captured at the right corner can turn a dead end into a lead. At the April council meeting, Sgt. Patrick Zayicek pointed to the Wood Ranch homicide, a jewelry store burglary and “jugging” robberies, in which thieves follow customers from banks. Without the cameras, he has said, many such cases would go inactive.
Police also used the cameras on July 21 to find a man they said they had probable cause to arrest for domestic battery and elder abuse; his family told officers he was armed and had threatened to “shoot it out.” A camera spotted his truck hours later. He fled, and after a pursuit through the city, officers shot and killed him. Police later said he was not armed. The camera's role ended when it located the truck; the shooting itself is under review by the California Department of Justice.
Zayicek also said that in his time, the department had made no immigration arrests and brought no abortion-related cases using the system. And while a Washington Post investigation found dozens of officers nationwide accused of using such cameras to track people, often former partners, no such case involving a Simi Valley officer has been reported.
The law has largely been on the department's side. A driver on public roads has no reasonable expectation of privacy in his movements, the U.S. Supreme Court held in 1983, and a license plate is displayed for anyone to see. Nearly every court to consider plate readers has found police need no warrant to use them, including a federal judge who upheld Norfolk, Va.'s Flock cameras in January. In California, an appeals court ruled in July, in a case against a private plate-reader company, that drivers suing under the state's plate-reader law must show actual harm, not simply that their plates were recorded.
That consensus has limits. In 2018 the Supreme Court required a warrant for weeks of cellphone location records, even though each movement happens in public, and critics say camera networks work the same way. In October, a federal judge in Oklahoma agreed in one case, and the Norfolk ruling is on appeal.
Support reaches beyond the department. Even while suspending its cameras, Oxnard's police department called the technology highly valuable, and Gov. Gavin Newsom, vetoing tighter state limits last year, warned that short data-retention windows could cost investigators evidence in cold cases.
Councilmember Joseph Ayala, who met with concerned residents for several hours before the April meeting, said the presentation answered what they had wanted to know.
What Went Wrong, and What Residents Are Asking
State law bars local agencies from sharing plate data with federal or out-of-state agencies, though it has often been broken: a 2023 review found 71 California agencies in violation, and Attorney General Rob Bonta sued El Cajon last year over its sharing.
On Feb. 27, Simi Valley, Oxnard and the Ventura County Sheriff's Office each disclosed that a Flock feature called “national lookup,” which they had switched off to comply, had been turned back on without their knowledge. The sheriff's audit found outside agencies searched its data more than 364,000 times in one month of 2025, 299 times citing immigration.
Simi Valley's audit found two searches, both by police at a Veterans Affairs medical center in Loma Linda; the city said both were criminal cases and that Flock cut off the agency's access. Oxnard suspended its cameras; Simi Valley kept its running.
At the April 6 council meeting, residents asked about Flock's changing terms of service, its security and whether audit logs would be made public. One woman asked how the city would guarantee transparency about any changes; another resident asked how it keeps the data from being used for immigration enforcement. Others want maps of camera locations. The American Civil Liberties Union argues that companies like Flock are “quietly trying to build a nationwide mass surveillance system.”
Supporters, including Flock, say that framing does not hold up. No city is required to buy the cameras, and each community decides whether to install them, how many, how long to keep the data and who can see it. Flock says agencies own their data and set local policy, and cities can limit the kinds of searches other agencies run. Simi Valley's council chose its cameras, and the department sets its own retention and sharing rules. Other communities have chosen less surveillance, as Los Angeles and Oxnard did. Critics respond that the February error showed a vendor's settings can override a city's choices.
Flock says it disabled national lookup for all California agencies in March 2025, and immigration-related searches are now automatically blocked in California. The company has promised to require case codes and audit tools by the end of 2026.
The Real Question: Do the Cameras Help Solve Crimes?
The short answer: yes in individual cases, unproven in the aggregate. Police here mostly argue that the cameras help solve crimes by turning a vehicle description into a suspect, not that they deter crime, and the evidence is somewhat stronger for that claim.
Locally, the examples are concrete. Besides the Oct. 29 arrest, cameras flagged a stolen car on June 21 driven by a 14-year-old, and a car stolen from Newport Beach last November near Stearns Street and the 118.
The research is more qualified. A nationwide working paper covering 216 agencies found the share of vehicle thefts cleared by arrest rose about 16 percent after cameras went up, but the rise began before installation. In Cleveland, the combined closure rate for robbery, assault and burglary rose from 15.5 to 18.7 percent, though the city could not count how many cases the cameras helped solve. A review by the Los Angeles Police Department's inspector general, covering August and September 2025, credited plate readers with 337 recovered cars and 74 arrests, along with 161 stops of cars wrongly believed stolen. A Charlotte, N.C., study found gains that were not statistically significant.
Other figures diverge sharply. Flock has said its cameras help solve 10 percent of reported crime and now advertises 15 percent; a researcher whose name was on the 10 percent study later questioned it. A 2021 report by the Independent Institute and the privacy group Secure Justice found fewer than 0.3 percent of hits in Piedmont, Calif., became useful leads.
The pattern: case closures tick up after cameras arrive, but the gains are modest and hard to separate from other factors. As Cleveland officials put it, detectives can often say a camera helped solve a case, not that it solved it alone.
Prevention is harder still to show. The national paper found an 11 percent drop in vehicle thefts, but only under some analyses, and California thefts fell nearly 26 percent statewide in 2025, a drop officials credited to crackdowns on theft rings, so a local decline cannot be credited to cameras alone.
Simi Valley has not released the figures that would let residents judge: how many alerts led to arrests or recoveries, how many were false alarms, and whether solve rates changed after November 2023. Those numbers would not settle the privacy debate, but they would show whether what the cameras deliver here is worth what they collect.
If It Were Your Car, or Your Child
In a Harris Poll survey this spring, 94 percent of Americans said they would expect cameras to help solve a crime against them in a public place. The survey was paid for by a company that sells cameras and plate readers.
For car-theft victims, the benefit is direct: a stolen car's plate goes on a hot list, and the next camera it passes alerts officers. That is how Simi Valley's publicized arrests began, including a car stolen in Hollywood that officers stopped in a Walmart parking lot on July 1.
The stakes are highest when a child is taken. Since 2021, through a partnership with the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, vehicles in Amber Alerts have been sent to Flock's network, reaching police hot lists within minutes, and the system can flag a car even without a full plate.
In September 2025, a 1-year-old was taken at knifepoint from his mother at a Los Angeles County Target. A Flock camera near Flagstaff, Ariz., flagged the suspects' car, and the boy was found safe that day. Flock credits its cameras in other abductions, including six in Colorado. No Amber Alert case involving Simi Valley's cameras has been reported.
But victims are not the only people the cameras touch. In 2020, police in Aurora, Colo., held a Black mother and four girls at gunpoint after a plate reader wrongly matched her car to a stolen motorcycle; the city paid $1.9 million to settle. People tracked by officers misusing the systems were victims too.
Opinion reflects the tension. In a Reuters/Ipsos poll, 47 percent of Americans opposed Flock cameras in their communities and 38 percent supported them, while a Flock-commissioned poll in Cleveland found support strongest for responding to violent crime and finding missing persons.
Would you want the cameras if you were the victim? Most people say yes. The harder question, critics say, is whether you would want them if you were the driver wrongly stopped.
What Comes Next, and How to Weigh In
The four-year contract approved in 2023 sets up a renewal vote. Meanwhile, Flock now recommends keeping images seven days rather than 30; the department's page lists 30. The A.C.L.U. welcomed the shorter window but said Flock was treating privacy concerns as “mere public relations problems.”
State rules are unchanged after Newsom's veto of a bill requiring 60-day deletion and state audits, and a 2026 successor bill stalled in the Assembly in August.
Residents can read the department's plate reader policy and transparency portal, file a public records request for search logs or the list of agencies with access, as residents elsewhere have done, and speak at council meetings when the contract returns.
For now, the two sides describe the same cameras very differently. Zayicek put the department's view simply in April: “It's pictures only.” Critics do not dispute that. Their question is how many pictures there are, how long they are kept, and who may someday get to look.
The Simi Valley Ledger is an Official Publication of The Freedom Project © 2026
The Simi Valley Ledger in Simi Valley's Investigative News Source.
We are telling Simi Valley's Story
Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss a story.
We care about your data in our privacy policy.
